CRE Debt in 2027: Navigating Higher-Rate Realities

Plan for the expected and mitigate for the obstacles.

Tony Kaufmann
Tony Kaufman by SRK Headshot Day

Change is in the air as we near the end of a tumultuous year. So, as we enter 2027, where should our attention be as CRE finance professionals? It is important to recognize that in between the unprecedented days and an unrelenting news cycle fueling uncertainty, the economy continues to perform. Employment is strong. Consumer spending remains resilient. AI continues a rapid advance. At the same time, the recent midterm elections have set the stage for a new political landscape and clearly change is on the horizon as we digest the shift.

Expect continued rate volatility in what will remain a “higher for longer” climate. The unknowns? Persistent inflation, geopolitical conflicts, energy market disruptions, trade policy, the cost of AI buildout and growing federal debt will continue to pressure rates. How will all this influence financing and what should we consider relevant for CRE? Here are some thoughts to shape our conversations.

Expectations for sustained debt liquidity and availability

This is a bright spot for CRE. Lenders continue showing a sustained appetite for lending with ample liquidity to deploy, creating an active marketplace for new originations. Most plan to maintain or even increase allocations to their CRE debt portfolios in 2027. For borrowers, this means continued access to a motivated and competitive lending field for options, even as a higher rate climate creates challenges. This competition is pushing lenders to loosen some of their underwriting criteria to put money to work, which can result in favorable terms including higher proceeds, interest-only options and prepayment flexibility. The demand to place debt is ultimately reshaping lender risk profiles to favor qualifying borrowers.

CPE Capital Markets Newsletter

Executive Editor Therese Fitzgerald delivers the capital markets intel that moves the needle.

Rate climate and refinancing

It is the front-of-mind topic shaping our industry conversations. With the Mortgage Bankers Association reporting approximately $652 billion of scheduled maturities in 2027, the current rate climate will shape refinancing of this cycle’s maturities in a major way. The maturity schedules could grow larger as recent extensions begin to run out and lenders become less patient. There will be challenges for even conservatively financed properties.

Conservative loans originally underwritten to a 65 percent LTV are now transitioning from a 3.25 percent rate to what is now roughly 6.25 percent at refinance. Maybe rents have increased but so have costs. Debt service bandwidth is driving loan sizing in today’s marketplace. This will generate more distress, requiring more creativity to solve for solution. Don’t expect this to be cataclysmic. But at current rates, achieving the necessary proceeds for even a cash-neutral refinance will require identifying viable structures, diligent underwriting and, in many cases, a fresh equity infusion or, ultimately, a compelled sale for a reset to the current cost of capital.

An early start will be crucial

Holding out for or anticipating a dramatic change in the rate climate is no longer a viable strategy. Timing will be of the essence moving into 2027. Be early to the process: Sourcing options with time to align the necessary due diligence will be key to successful outcomes. Look to lock in rates where feasible. The pressures shaping Treasury yields and SOFR are very unlikely to moderate any time soon. All indicators point to the Federal Reserve planning for rate increases beginning in December with additional movement expected next year. Improvement of any underlying conditions will be a benefit, but a return to sub 3.5 percent rate climate in any near-term scenario remains highly unlikely for the foreseeable future.

Image by abdul studio/Adobe Stock

Fixed-rate vs. floating-rate appeal

We should expect fixed-rate options to become more appealing as we move into 2027. The rate volatility of recent years had many borrowers looking for the cheapest cost of capital and, for many, a floating-rate execution provided that. The attraction may be shifting. For borrowers gravitating to five- or three-year terms with floating-rate executions, the inherent risk of a variable rate is now clear with upward pressures on rate-setting benchmarks. Spreads on floating-rate debt are still wider in the high 100s from 175 to 190. Fixed-rate spreads remain in the low-mid 100s for reasonably leveraged, core assets. With rate hikes all but certain, we should expect to see a parallel increase in base SOFR. More borrowers today are worrying about the long-term direction of rates, making the stability of permanent debt attractive again.

The case for longer-term permanent loans

Longer-term permanent debt is also becoming an appealing option again as the spread between five-year and 10-year Treasury yields compresses and lenders become more willing to incorporate prepayment flexibility in longer-term maturities. Earlier this year, the spread between the five-year and 10-year was roughly 45 bps—now it is at roughly 20 bps. There were a lot of borrowers gravitating to shorter-term borrowing for its flexibility when refinancing in a hopefully improved rate climate. Borrowers still want to preserve flexibility, but as lenders compete with flexibility options, interest in seven- to 10-year requests should grow.

Policy climate

The recent outcome of the midterm elections is poised to provide a new type of stability: gridlock. The ability to push through new policy shifts with far-reaching impacts will be curtailed as the executive and congressional branches transition to a new dynamic. However, the debt ceiling will be an early test for just how vitriolic the next two years will be. It will also be a test for how volatile the rate climate might become in the year ahead. Most projections see us reaching the current debt ceiling established in 2025 somewhere between the late winter and early summer of 2027. If there is a struggle to achieve consensus on a go-forward strategy to deal with the national debt, we could see a renewed period of volatility in Treasuries and other underlying benchmarks as markets respond to dysfunction.

Expect a year of hard work ahead

The forecast for 2027 is not one of doom and gloom. Much is going well. Abundant liquidity continues to define the debt markets. Banks are as active as they have ever been as a source for new debt, and insurance companies, CMBS, debt funds and private capital sources continue to compete aggressively for their market share of new loans. Performance is mostly holding strong across the major asset classes, including industrial and retail, with office continuing to show a comeback. Hospitality is performing after a post-COVID reset. Where there is weakening, the dearth of new construction is helping tighten vacancy and improve performance. The rate climate will be the real challenge for the year ahead and the work will be in navigating the competitive debt markets, developing realistic business plans and charting your best and final course across the sea of options to reach the desired outcome.

Tony Kaufmann is a principal at Gantry.

Please note: To become a Viewpoint writer, reach out to Therese Fitzgerald at therese.fitzgerald@cpe-mhn.com. All Viewpoints are copyright of Commercial Property Executive. We do not accept AI-written content.