Paradise Isle Plaza on Longboat Key

For Sale

5610 Gulf Of Mexico Dr, Longboat Key, FL 34228

This Longboat Key property for sale is located at 5610 Gulf Of Mexico Dr. The current listed sale price for Paradise Isle Plaza on Longboat Key is $3,250,000. Paradise Isle Plaza on Longboat Key is situated on a lot that is 1.3 acre in size.

Contacts

Adam Doak

American Property Group of Sarasota

Property Details

  • Property Type Retail
  • Property Size 9,611 SF
  • Lot Size 1.3 Acre
  • Property Tenancy Multi-Tenant
  • Year Built 1986
  • Year Renovated 2024
  • Date Updated May 20, 2026
Situs Address: 5610 GULF OF MEXICO DR, LONGBOAT KEY, FL 34228-1900 Jurisdiction: TOWN OF LONGBOAT KEY Tax District: 0256; LONGBOAT KEY BAYSIDE DISTRICT Sec/Twp/Rge: 25-35S-16E Neighborhood: 7005; ISLAND Condominium: 7958800; NORTH KEY PLAZAParadise Isle Plaza presents a rare opportunity to acquire a well-established multi-tenant retail investment property in the heart of Longboat Key. Exclusively offered by American Property GroupAttachment.png, this highly visible neighborhood shopping plaza is located at 5610 Gulf of Mexico Drive and benefits from strong frontage along one of the island’s primary corridors. Situated on approximately 1.3 acres, Paradise Isle Plaza offers approximately 9,611 SF of leasable space across six retail suites with an abundance of on-site parking for both customers and employees. The property has been exceptionally maintained and features a strong, long-standing tenant mix that serves both the local community and the area’s steady stream of visitors. Current tenants include: - Guppy’s Pub Fare - Backyard Bike Shop - Ana’s Breakfast and Lunch Cafe - Penny’s Ice Cream - Costello’s Pizzeria & Wings - Le Gardenia Bleu Home, Gift, and Floral Studio - Suite A (A1) will be oMultfficially vacant and is currently being marketed to be the frontage unit/anchor tenant of this plaza with approx. 1,973 sf. All tenant leases are structured as NNN leases, providing investors with stable income and reduced landlord responsibilities. An additional standout feature of this offering is the included deeded beach access, further enhancing the long-term desirability and uniqueness of the property. With a proven operating history, established tenant base, excellent parking, and a premier Longboat Key location, Paradise Isle Plaza represents an exceptional investment opportunity in one of Florida’s most sought-after coastal communities. *For Income information please complete the NDA attached to the brochure
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Highlights

  • All tenant leases structured as NNN leases, minimizing landlord expenses
  • Approximately 9,611 SF of leasable retail space
  • Diverse tenant mix including restaurants, retail, service, and specialty businesses
  • Excellent opportunity for investors seeking stable income in a premier coastal market
  • Includes valuable deeded beach access, enhancing the property’s uniqueness and appeal
  • Positioned on approximately 1.3 acres with an abundance of on-site parking
  • Prime multi-tenant retail investment opportunity located on highly desirable Longboat Key
  • Situated along Gulf of Mexico Drive with excellent visibility and accessibility
  • Six fully leased retail suites with established long-term tenants
  • Well-maintained shopping plaza with strong curb appeal and consistent customer traffic

Attachments

Getting around

  • 34/100

    Walk Score ®

  • 51/100

    Bike Score ®

Powered by Walk Score ®

Location

  • City Longboat Key, FL
  • Zip Code 34228
  • Market Southwest Florida Coast

Points of Interest

  • Shell

    3.93 miles

  • BP

    4.12 miles

  • Walmart

    4.28 miles

  • Citgo

    4.51 miles

  • Mobil

    4.53 miles

  • Marathon

    5.19 miles

  • Speedway

    5.21 miles

  • Circle K

    5.48 miles

  • 7-Eleven

    5.49 miles

  • Tesla Destination Charger

    7.63 miles

  • Starbucks parking

    3.64 miles

  • Overflow Parking

    4.48 miles

  • Robinson Preserve South Parking Lot

    5.67 miles

  • Neal Preserve parking

    5.83 miles

  • Rental Car Parking

    6.79 miles

  • Short Term Parking

    6.86 miles

  • Long Term Parking

    6.90 miles

  • Shade Parking

    7.02 miles

  • Overflow Lot A

    7.13 miles

  • Lewis Park parking lot

    7.20 miles

  • Harry's Continental Kitechens

    0.03 miles

  • Harry's Gourmet Deli

    0.04 miles

  • Bayou Tavern

    1.94 miles

  • Mar Vista Dockside Restaurant

    2.07 miles

  • The Shore

    2.09 miles

  • Ghost Street Kitchen

    3.50 miles

  • McDonald's

    3.71 miles

  • Star Fish Company

    3.88 miles

  • Mattison's

    3.92 miles

  • RJ Gator's

    4.05 miles

  • Winn-Dixie

    3.71 miles

  • Marshalls

    3.75 miles

  • CGX

    3.93 miles

  • Publix

    3.94 miles

  • Walmart Supercenter

    4.19 miles

  • Bealls Outlet

    4.52 miles

  • ALDI

    4.53 miles

  • TJ Maxx

    5.17 miles

  • Target

    5.17 miles

  • Kabayan Oriental Market

    5.31 miles

Contact Listing Broker
Adam Doak

American Property Group of Sarasota

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.