228 East Main Street

For Sale

228 East Main Street, Port Jefferson, NY 11777

This Port Jefferson property for sale is located at 228 East Main Street. The current listed sale price for 228 East Main Street is $1,849,000. 228 East Main Street is situated on a lot that is 0.14 acre in size.

Contacts

Lee Rosner, SIOR CCIM

NAI Long Island

Property Details

  • Property Type Retail - Street Retail
  • Property Size 8,535 SF
  • Lot Size 0.14 Acre
  • Parking Spaces Avail. 5
  • Property Tenancy Multi-Tenant
  • Year Built 1900
  • Date Updated May 6, 2026
Discover the vibrant community surrounding The Vault at Port Jefferson. Nestled in the heart of Port Jefferson, NY, this bustling area offers a charming blend of historic architecture, artisanal shops, and diverse dining options. Stroll along East Main Street to experience a welcoming atmosphere and a strong sense of local pride. Just a short distance away to the north, the picturesque Port Jefferson Harbor provides a stunning backdrop for leisurely walks and outdoor gatherings. Nearby attractions include the Long Island Museum and the scenic Belle Terre Beach. With its desirable location and strong community appeal, The Vault at Port Jefferson presents an exceptional investment opportunity for retail and street retail investors. This prime property is ideally located in Port Jefferson's vibrant downtown, bordered by Port Jefferson Harbor to the north and the LIRR to the south. The harbor provides access to the Bridgeport/Port Jefferson Ferry, offering a convenient route from Long Island's North Shore to Bridgeport, CT, and New England. To the south, the LIRR Port Jefferson branch offers direct access to Queens and NYC. Within a 10-minute drive to Stony Brook University & Hospital, providing a massive built-in demographic of professionals and students. St. Charles Hospital is located two miles east. The area has undergone significant revitalization in recent years, with numerous mixed-use and residential multi-family developments adding hundreds of new residential units, bolstering the Main Street retail environment. Even more projects are planned for Port Jefferson and its surrounding areas.Introducing a prime investment opportunity at 228 East Main Street, a well-maintained 8,535 SF (including LL) retail/office building in Port Jefferson, N.Y. Located in the heart of the iconic waterfront village, 228 East Main Street is a premier multi-use property that blends historic character with modern commercial utility. Situated on the primary "main-to-main" corridor, the building benefits from year-round local patronage and heavy seasonal tourism driven by the Port Jefferson Ferry and Harborfront Park.
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Highlights

  • Former Bank Building: The structure retains its original prestige as a historic financial institution (originally the First National Bank of Port Jefferson, built circa 1900).
  • Ground Floor (Retail): Roughly 3,340 SF of prime retail space with large storefront windows, high ceilings, and an open floor plan designed for maximum foot traffic flow.
  • Location: Located in the heart of the Port Jefferson Village's business and medical community.
  • Lower Level: +/-2,932 SF of above-grade lower-level space with immediate ground-floor access to Traders Cove, a large municipal parking lot.Strategic
  • Parking: On-site parking for 5 cars in the rear as well as on-street parking and the immediately adjacent Traders Cove municipal lot.
  • Proximity: Located less than 1/4 mile south of the Port Jefferson Ferry.
  • Second Floor (Office/Residential): +/-2,262 SF that is ideal for professional office suites (i.e. Co-Working) or high-end apartments, featuring excellent views of the village.
  • Taxes: $51,210, including PJ Village Taxes. Not grieved!
  • Zoning: Zoned C1 (Central Commercial), allowing for a wide variety of uses including retail, bank, law firm, professional medical offices, as well as residential use.

Attachments

Getting around

  • 78/100

    Walk Score ®

  • 39/100

    Bike Score ®

Powered by Walk Score ®

Location

  • City Port Jefferson, NY
  • Zip Code 11777
  • Market Long Island

Points of Interest

  • Port Jefferson

    1.03 miles

  • Port Jefferson Train Station

    1.04 miles

  • Highlands Boulevard

    1.12 miles

  • Railroad Avenue

    1.14 miles

  • Platform B

    3.56 miles

  • Platform A

    3.56 miles

  • Stony Brook

    3.59 miles

  • Platform B - Crossover

    3.64 miles

  • Platform A - Crossover

    3.65 miles

  • Saint James

    6.42 miles

  • Speedway

    1.32 miles

  • Setauket Gulf

    2.21 miles

  • ChargePoint

    3.93 miles

  • BP

    4.32 miles

  • Penney's North Country Gas

    4.61 miles

  • Valero

    5.84 miles

  • Mobil

    6.07 miles

  • Admin Overflow

    3.29 miles

  • Stadium Lot

    3.44 miles

  • Health Sciences

    3.44 miles

  • Administration Parking Garage

    3.50 miles

  • Chemistry

    3.62 miles

  • Staff Parking Lot A

    3.64 miles

  • Hospital Parking Garage

    3.66 miles

  • SAC Lot

    3.68 miles

  • H Lot

    3.83 miles

  • Old Field Club Parking

    3.99 miles

  • Pasta Pasta

    0.01 miles

  • Revival by Toast

    0.03 miles

  • Joey Z's

    0.04 miles

  • Barito Tacos & Cocktails

    0.05 miles

  • The Pie

    0.06 miles

  • Salsa Salsa

    0.06 miles

  • Tiger Lily Cafe

    0.06 miles

  • The Whiskey Barrel

    0.07 miles

  • Dunkin'

    0.08 miles

  • Prohibition Port Jeff

    0.09 miles

  • The Amazing Olive

    0.05 miles

  • Harbor Square Mall

    0.08 miles

  • Ideal Food Basket

    1.25 miles

  • Meat Farms

    1.99 miles

  • Stop & Shop

    2.22 miles

  • Wild by Nature

    2.25 miles

  • King Kullen

    2.25 miles

  • Uncle Giuseppes'

    2.35 miles

  • Walmart

    3.00 miles

  • Shop Red West

    3.54 miles

Contact Listing Broker
Lee Rosner, SIOR CCIM

NAI Long Island

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.