5059 New York 23

For Sale

5059 New York 23, Oneonta, NY 13820

This Oneonta property for sale is located at 5059 New York 23. The current listed sale price for 5059 New York 23 is $1,600,000. 5059 New York 23 is situated on a lot that is 1.12 acre in size.

Contacts

Lisberto Calvo

SVN | Innovative Commercial Advisors

Property Details

  • Property Type Other
  • Property Size 5,910 SF
  • Units 16
  • Lot Size 1.12 Acre
  • Date Updated Sep 29, 2026
5059 NY-23 is positioned along the primary commercial route serving Southside Oneonta, directly across from Walmart Supercenter and within an established concentration of national and regional retail, dining, hospitality and service businesses. The surrounding commercial area includes major operators such as BJ's Wholesale Club, ALDI, Dick's Sporting Goods, T.J. Maxx, Panera Bread and Applebee's, supporting consistent consumer activity along NY-23. The property also benefits from convenient access to I-88, Downtown Oneonta, SUNY Oneonta and Hartwick College, with Cooperstown and Cooperstown All Star Village contributing additional regional tourism and hospitality demand. This combination of highway access, retail activity, institutional demand and regional visitation supports both the property's existing hospitality use and its longer-term commercial positioning.5059 NY-23 is a 1.12-acre commercial property improved with an approximately 5,910 SF, 16-room motel in Oneonta's established Southside commercial area. The property offers direct NY-23 frontage, on-site parking and access at a signalized intersection, with Walmart Supercenter positioned directly across the roadway. The existing hospitality configuration provides immediate utility while preserving the site's longer-term repositioning potential. Surrounded by national and regional retailers, restaurants, hotels and service businesses, the property offers multiple potential investment strategies. Buyers may evaluate continued hospitality use, repositioning of the existing improvements or future commercial redevelopment based on their investment objectives. The combination of existing improvements, commercial visibility and a 1.12-acre site creates optionality for investors, developers and owner-users, subject to zoning and municipal approvals.
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Highlights

  • 1.12-Acre Commercial Site
  • 16-Room Existing Motel
  • Directly Across from Walmart
  • Established Commercial Location
  • Repositioning & Redevelopment Potential
  • Signalized NY-23 Access

Attachments

Getting around

  • 48/100

    Walk Score ®

  • 24/100

    Bike Score ®

Powered by Walk Score ®

Location

  • City Oneonta, NY
  • Zip Code 13820

Points of Interest

  • Speedway

    0.42 miles

  • Mirabito

    0.57 miles

  • BJ's Gas

    0.61 miles

  • Sunoco

    8.64 miles

  • Quickway

    9.82 miles

  • Oneonta Parking Garage

    1.09 miles

  • Student Parking

    1.35 miles

  • Teachers Parking

    1.41 miles

  • Anderson Improved Lot

    1.55 miles

  • Anderson Lot

    1.55 miles

  • Lower Yager Lot

    1.58 miles

  • Smith Lot

    1.58 miles

  • Yager Lot

    1.60 miles

  • Wilder Lot and Yager Lot

    1.60 miles

  • Leitzell & Van Ness Lots

    1.62 miles

  • Budget Inn

    0.00 miles

  • Super 8

    0.41 miles

  • Holiday Inn Express & Suites

    0.41 miles

  • Courtyard Oneonta

    0.57 miles

  • Quality Inn

    0.75 miles

  • Hampton Inn Oneonta

    2.36 miles

  • Walmart Supercenter

    0.16 miles

  • South Side Mall

    0.23 miles

  • TJ Maxx

    0.30 miles

  • ALDI

    0.57 miles

  • Hannaford

    0.84 miles

  • Green Earth Health Food Market

    1.15 miles

  • Clinton Street Plaza

    1.15 miles

Contact Listing Broker
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.