95 W. Lake Road

For Sale

95 W. Lake Road, Mayville, NY 14757

This Mayville property for sale is located at 95 W. Lake Road. The general use of 95 W. Lake Road is retail and it incorporates 2,400 square feet of class C retail space. The current listed sale price for 95 W. Lake Road is $495,000.

Contacts

Sherry Bauer

SBRE - Sherry Bauer Real Estate

Property Details

  • Property Type Retail - Restaurant
  • Property Size 2,400 SF
  • Units 1
  • Parking Spaces Avail. 30
  • Property Tenancy Single Tenant
  • Building Class C
  • Year Built 1950
  • Year Renovated 2025
  • Date Updated May 26, 2026
Route 394 / W. Lake Road at Meadow Lane & Mather Road. Across street from Chautauqua Lake & Chautauqua Marina.2,400± SF turnkey, 2nd generation lakefront restaurant with indoor, outdoor & boat-up dining and beautiful lake views now available for sale. Situated on a corner lot across from Chautauqua Lake in the Village of Mayville, NY. Completely renovated in 2023 including electrical, kitchen, flooring, HVAC & more. Additional updates including new dining room windows (2024) & new deck (2025). Currently owner operated as She Sings Café & Bar. Sale includes real property & equipment only. Fully equipped commercial kitchen – equipment list available. Indoor seating for ±88 with table seating for ±72 & bar seating for ±16. Additional outdoor seating on large deck with lake views. Full, walk-out lower level for storage with 11’ x 14’ walk-in cooler, 15’ x 11’ dry food storage room, employee restroom & overhead door for deliveries. 3D tour & floor plan available. Off-street parking for ±30 & boat docking arrangement for ±3 slips. Multiple nearby tourism attractions: Chautauqua Institution, Chautauqua Lake fishing & water sports, Midway State Park, the National Comedy Center, Lucille Ball Desi Arnaz Museum, Roger Tory Peterson Institute, Robert H. Jackson Center, Audubon Community Nature Center, Peek’n Peak & more. Centrally located in the tri-state area just 40 miles (50 minutes) to Erie, PA; 75 miles (1.25 hours) to Buffalo, NY; 130 miles (2 hours) to Cleveland, OH and 165 miles (2.5 hours) to Pittsburgh, PA. Offered at $495,000. Contact broker for additional information or to schedule a tour.
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Highlights

  • 2,400± SF Turnkey, 2nd Generation Lakefront Restaurant
  • 3D Tour & Floor Plan Available
  • Across From Chautauqua Lake In The Village Of Mayville, NY
  • Additional Outdoor Seating On Large Deck With Lake Views
  • Completely Renovated In 2023 Including Electrical, Kitchen, Flooring, HVAC & More
  • Currently Owner Operated As She Sings Café & Bar
  • Full, Walk-Out Lower Level For Storage With 11’ x 14’ Walk-In Cooler, Dry Food Storage Room, Employee Restroom & Overhead Door For Deliveries
  • Fully Equipped Commercial Kitchen – Equipment List Available
  • Indoor Seating For ±88: Table Seating For ±72 & Bar Seating For ±16
  • Near Multiple Tourism Attractions: Chautauqua Institution, Chautauqua Lake Fishing & Water Sports, Midway State Park, The National Comedy Center, Lucille Ball Desi Arnaz Museum, Roger Tory Peterson Institute, Robert H. Jackson Center, Audubon Community Nature Center, Peek’n Peak & More
  • New Dining Room Windows (2024) & New Deck (2025)
  • Offered At $495,000
  • Off-Street Parking For ±30 & Boat Docking Arrangement For ±3 Slips
  • Sale Includes Real Property & Equipment Only
  • Turnkey With All Equipment Included
  • With Indoor, Outdoor & Boat-Up Dining & Beautiful Lake Views

Getting around

  • 25/100

    Walk Score ®

  • 39/100

    Bike Score ®

Powered by Walk Score ®

Location

  • City Mayville, NY
  • Zip Code 14757

Points of Interest

  • Crosby's

    1.23 miles

  • Mobil

    7.17 miles

  • EvConnect

    7.22 miles

  • Hogan's Hut

    7.34 miles

  • Bemus Bay Water Toys

    7.52 miles

  • Bridgeview One Stop

    8.22 miles

  • Barcelona Market Cafe

    8.74 miles

  • Visitor Short Term Parking

    2.52 miles

  • West Side Overland Hiking Trail - Rt 430

    2.85 miles

  • Guppy's

    5.40 miles

  • West Side Overland Hiking Trail - Mt. Pleasant & Titus

    5.42 miles

  • Webb's

    0.07 miles

  • Andriaccio's Restaurant

    2.22 miles

  • 3 Taps

    2.54 miles

  • The Brick Walk

    2.54 miles

  • Green Door Tavern

    5.07 miles

  • Guppys Restaurant and Tavern

    5.40 miles

  • McDonald's

    7.16 miles

  • Westfield Main Diner

    7.16 miles

  • Brazill's On Main

    7.18 miles

  • Annex 25

    7.19 miles

  • Tops

    1.09 miles

  • California Dreamin'

    7.21 miles

  • Bemus Point Market

    7.57 miles

Contact Listing Broker
Sherry Bauer

SBRE - Sherry Bauer Real Estate

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.