The Reserve at Petoskey

For Sale

501 W Mitchell St, Petoskey, MI 49770

This Petoskey property for sale is located at 501 W Mitchell St. The current listed sale price for The Reserve at Petoskey is $750,000. The Reserve at Petoskey is situated on a lot that is 0.5 acre in size.

Contacts

broker
Ryan Vinco

Encore Real Estate Investment Services

Property Details

  • Property Type Retail - Street Retail
  • Property Size 6,496 SF
  • Units 5
  • Lot Size 0.5 Acre
  • Property Tenancy Multi-Tenant
  • Year Built 1970
  • Date Updated Jul 24, 2025
er.
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Highlights

  • A?uent, Year-Round Market – Located in a stable, high-income resort community with strong seasonal tourism to boost business
  • Brand New Regional Lease – New 5-year lease with Cottage Inn Pizza, a trusted regional franchise with decades of brand recognition and a loyal customer base; long-term occupancy history supports stable, reliable income
  • Comprehensive Build-out & Upgraded Systems – Cottage Inn will be doing an extensive interior build-out, but also an upgrade in all electrical and HVAC systems to the building to ensure modern functionality and reduce maintenance costs
  • Cottage Inn Pizza Sets Goal is to Reach 100 Stores within 12 months!
  • Excellent Access & Parking – Easy ingress/egress with on-site parking; minutes from downtown, major retailers, and area amenities
  • Existing Tenants Occupied the Property 14, 12 and 4 years, Respectively
  • Flexible Commercial Use – Con?gured for retail, o?ce, medical, or service users; adaptable layout supports a wide range of businesses
  • Healthcare-Adjacent Location – Directly across from McLaren Northern Michigan Hospital (400+ beds), ideal for medical or service-oriented tenants
  • New Roof Unit 1 and 2 ($34,000) and Parking Lot Seal and Stripe 2024 Unit 3 and 4 Roof was Replaced in 2013 Concrete Replacement 2023 ($17,275)
  • Prime Visibility & Location – 144 Feet of Frontage along W Mitchell St (US-31), Petoskey’s main commercial corridor with strong daily tra?c counts
  • The Heart of Petoskey, MI - Nearly 1 MILLION Visitors Annually from Across the United States and the World www.petoskeyarea.com
  • Thriving Commercial Hub – Surrounded by national retailers, restaurants, medical o?ces, and local businesses generating steady foot tra?c
  • Upside in Rent Appreciation and Converting Leases from Gross to NNN

Getting around

  • 70/100

    Walk Score ®

  • 62/100

    Bike Score ®

Powered by Walk Score ®

Location

  • City Petoskey, MI
  • Zip Code 49770

Points of Interest

  • Marathon

    0.09 miles

  • BP

    0.34 miles

  • Next Door Store

    0.34 miles

  • Petoskey Pacific Pride

    0.87 miles

  • JBJ Trucking

    1.80 miles

  • Meijer

    1.89 miles

  • Mobil

    2.51 miles

  • D&W Quick Stop

    2.63 miles

  • Citgo

    2.69 miles

  • Shell

    3.02 miles

  • Bear River Trail Sheridan Street Trailhead

    0.64 miles

  • Little Traverse Wheelway Trailhead

    4.61 miles

  • Krause Rd

    5.17 miles

  • Challenger lot

    7.12 miles

  • Tanton Family Reserve MTB Trailhead

    7.60 miles

  • Boyne City School Forest Trail

    8.08 miles

  • Boyne Forest Trails - East Trailhead Parking Lot

    8.08 miles

  • Boyne Forest Trails - West Trailhead Parking Lot

    8.64 miles

  • East Brutus Road Trailhead Parking

    9.10 miles

  • Arby's

    0.10 miles

  • Nagoya

    0.17 miles

  • Jet's Pizza

    0.19 miles

  • Subway

    0.21 miles

  • McDonald's

    0.26 miles

  • Big Boy

    0.29 miles

  • Mancino's

    0.29 miles

  • Wendy's

    0.31 miles

  • Villa Ristorante

    0.36 miles

  • Burger King

    0.38 miles

  • Grain Train Natural Foods Market

    0.50 miles

  • Gordon Food Service

    0.71 miles

  • Big Lots

    0.88 miles

  • Walmart Supercenter

    1.64 miles

  • ALDI

    1.82 miles

  • Meijer

    1.84 miles

  • Louie's Fresh Market

    2.28 miles

  • D&W Fresh Market

    2.72 miles

  • Oleson's

    4.26 miles

  • Harbor Springs IGA

    4.47 miles

In-Depth Research Available for this Property

Access more in-depth information about this property — including ownership, tenant details, property characteristics and transaction history, along with local market insights and much more — on CommercialEdge.

Contact Listing Broker
broker
Ryan Vinco

Encore Real Estate Investment Services

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.