Coles County Rental Portfolio

For Sale

2505 Pine Ave, Mattoon, IL 61938

This Mattoon property for sale is located at 2505 Pine Ave. The current listed sale price for Coles County Rental Portfolio is $1,999,000. Coles County Rental Portfolio is situated on a lot that is 0.41 acre in size.

Contacts

Getty Greer

SVN | North Star

Property Details

  • Property Type Multi-Family
  • Property Size 4,872 SF
  • Units 33
  • Lot Size 0.41 Acre
  • Year Built 1975
  • Date Updated Apr 29, 2026
This portfolio is positioned across Mattoon and Charleston, two established communities in east-central Illinois. Charleston is anchored by Eastern Illinois University, which brings a steady stream of students, faculty, and staff to the local rental market. Mattoon sits just west on Interstate 57, providing direct north-south access to Champaign-Urbana, Effingham, and further connections to Chicago and St. Louis. U.S. Route 45 and Route 16 run through the trade area, keeping transportation straightforward. Mattoon has a population around 17,000 and functions as a regional employment hub with distribution, healthcare, and light manufacturing. Charleston adds another 17,000 residents, with housing demand supported by the university and Coles County’s public institutions. Combined, the two towns offer a tenant base split between workforce housing, student rentals, and long-term local residents.This portfolio covers 11 parcels across Mattoon and Charleston with a mix of multifamily and single-family rentals. The package includes 22 multifamily units across two addresses plus 9 single-family homes ranging from duplexes to 3-, 4-, 5-, and 6-bedroom properties. All units are currently tenant-occupied and producing income, delivering an in-place 8.8% cap rate. Charleston benefits from Eastern Illinois University, which drives steady rental demand alongside government and healthcare employment. Mattoon serves as a regional employment center with healthcare, manufacturing, and logistics tenants, anchored by immediate access to Interstate 57. Together, these markets provide stable occupancy, affordable rents relative to larger metros, and a reliable tenant base spanning students, workforce housing, and long-term residents. This is a straightforward income-producing portfolio with immediate returns.
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Highlights

  • 11 Parcels
  • 22 Units
  • 9 SFRs
  • Eastern Illinois University
  • Employment Hub
  • Low Entry Barrier
  • NOI- $227,580
  • Sarah Bush Lincoln Health Center

Attachments

Getting around

  • 62/100

    Walk Score ®

  • 83/100

    Bike Score ®

Powered by Walk Score ®

Location

  • City Mattoon, IL
  • Zip Code 61938

Points of Interest

  • Casey's

    0.31 miles

  • Moto Mart

    0.41 miles

  • BP

    0.95 miles

  • Marathon

    1.00 miles

  • Citgo

    1.10 miles

  • Pacific 66

    1.13 miles

  • Huck's Food & Fuel

    1.37 miles

  • Murphy USA

    2.66 miles

  • Parking Lot C

    4.34 miles

  • Parking Lot A

    4.40 miles

  • Parking Lot D

    4.41 miles

  • Parking Lot B

    4.43 miles

  • Parking Lot E

    4.57 miles

  • Parking Lot F

    4.61 miles

  • US Grant Motel

    0.96 miles

  • Suite Dreams Hotel

    2.17 miles

  • Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites

    2.89 miles

  • Super 8

    3.16 miles

  • Clarion Pointe

    3.24 miles

  • Hampton

    3.25 miles

  • Comfort Inn

    3.30 miles

  • Hilton Garden Inn Mattoon

    4.10 miles

  • Big Lots

    2.02 miles

  • JCPenney

    2.28 miles

  • Cross County Mall

    2.35 miles

  • Walmart Supercenter

    2.59 miles

  • ALDI

    3.03 miles

Contact Listing Broker
Getty Greer

SVN | North Star

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.