58A Old Amity Road

For Sale

58A Old Amity Road, Bethany, CT 06524

This Bethany property for sale is located at 58A Old Amity Road. The current listed sale price for 58A Old Amity Road is $6,500,000. 58A Old Amity Road is situated on a lot that is 33 acre in size.

Contacts

broker
Paul Scalzo Sr.

Scalzo Commercial & New Development

Property Details

  • Property Type Multi-Family
  • Units 22
  • Lot Size 33 Acre
  • Property Tenancy Multi-Tenant
  • Year Built 2018
  • Date Updated Jul 28, 2025
Prime Location for Residential Development – Bethany, CT Located in New Haven County, Bethany offers a rare blend of rural character and accessibility. Just a short drive to downtown New Haven, Yale University, and major employment centers, the area appeals to homebuyers seeking a peaceful setting without sacrificing convenience. The site benefits from proximity to Route 63, Route 69, and I-84, providing seamless access to the broader New Haven, Waterbury, and Hartford markets. Bethany’s low-density zoning, strong community reputation, and access to nearby amenities make it an ideal setting for a high-quality residential development.Presenting a rare investment opportunity in Bethany, CT. This R-130 zoned, bank-owned property includes 22 completed townhomes, with approvals in place for three additional homes and the potential to develop three more on the approved clubhouse site. Additionally, the property holds approvals for eight more units, offering strong upside potential. With infrastructure already in place, this development is primed for expansion. Investors will appreciate the flexibility to operate the property as a multifamily rental community or convert it into a condominium complex with an established association. Whether you're seeking long-term rental income or a for-sale condo strategy, 58A Old Amity Rd presents a ready-to-go opportunity for growth and profitability.
Want more info on this listing?

Reach out to the broker for more info on lease terms and amenities

Highlights

  • 22 units
  • 7 wells and septic systems
  • Approvals for 8 additional units
  • Bank-owned property
  • Built in 2018
  • Clubhouse and pump house included
  • Zoned R-130

Getting around

  • 18/100

    Walk Score ®

  • 20/100

    Bike Score ®

Powered by Walk Score ®

Location

  • City Bethany, CT
  • Zip Code 06524
  • Market Bridgeport New Haven

Points of Interest

  • Seymour

    3.82 miles

  • Ansonia

    5.84 miles

  • Naugatuck

    6.77 miles

  • West Haven

    9.34 miles

  • Citgo

    3.28 miles

  • Shell

    3.69 miles

  • Stop & Shop Gas

    3.92 miles

  • Irving

    4.30 miles

  • Mobil

    4.49 miles

  • Philips 66

    4.50 miles

  • Pit Stop

    4.65 miles

  • Stop&Shop

    4.70 miles

  • Sunco

    4.72 miles

  • Tesla Supercharger

    4.90 miles

  • Connecticut Park and Ride

    5.09 miles

  • Wintergreen Parking Garage

    5.28 miles

  • Lot K

    6.81 miles

  • Lot 14

    6.83 miles

  • Lot 17

    6.86 miles

  • Lot 63

    6.92 miles

  • Clarion Hotel & Suites Hamden-New Haven

    5.24 miles

  • Comfort Inn

    5.56 miles

  • Cheshire Welcome Inn

    6.92 miles

  • Courtyard New Haven at Yale

    7.11 miles

  • Cambria Hotel New Haven University Area

    7.36 miles

  • The Study at Yale

    7.37 miles

  • The Study

    7.38 miles

  • Graduate by Hilton New Haven

    7.40 miles

  • Avalon

    7.60 miles

  • The Blake Hotel

    7.60 miles

  • Stop & Shop

    3.82 miles

  • ShopRite

    4.64 miles

  • Marshalls

    4.65 miles

  • Walmart

    4.65 miles

  • Kohl's

    4.66 miles

  • ALDI

    4.67 miles

  • Burlington

    4.67 miles

  • Super Stop & Shop

    4.72 miles

  • Walmart Supercenter

    4.89 miles

  • Price Rite

    4.90 miles

In-Depth Research Available for this Property

Access more in-depth information about this property — including ownership, tenant details, property characteristics and transaction history, along with local market insights and much more — on CommercialEdge.

Contact Listing Broker
broker
Paul Scalzo Sr.

Scalzo Commercial & New Development

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.